Posted By

Paige Daniels

Marketing Manager

Association Reserves, Inc

Profile | Blog

The Flaw of Averages!

By Robert M. Nordlund, PE, RS
Association Reserves, Inc.


Reserve Funding Objectives

The two most common Reserve Funding objectives are Full Funding, where the Reserve Fund is designed to exactly offset the amount of Association deterioration, and Baseline Funding, where the Reserve Fund is designed to stay cash-positive at all times.

Reserve Funding Methods

Full Funding objective is more conservative, because fully-funded Associations maintain a higher Reserve Balance through the years (i.e., as deterioration grows or falls, so does the Reserve Fund). So what could be wrong with an objective to stay cash-positive? Why should any Association store up extra cash in the bank?

Baseline Funding and The Flaw of Averages

The issue is clarified by what’s known as “The Flaw of Averages”, a book by Dr. Sam Savage, a professor of Management Science & Engineering at Stanford University. The problem with the “flaw of averages” can be easily shown in the following illustration.

Average depth Flaw of Averages comic

If one extreme side of a calculated “average” creates a critical problem, basing your actions on “average” can be foolish.
A tall and a short Basketball playerConsider this other example: Two basketball teams may “average” the same height of players, but if one team has a  significantlytaller player that can camp out under the offensive basket to score easy dunk shots, or present a key defensive obstacle, that team is more likely to win than the opposing team with players of about the same “average” height. So in basketball, having one player with a height that is “extremely above average” could be a real game-changer.

So what does all this talk of “averages” have to do with Reserve Funding?

Almost all associations have a healthy (20 or more) list of reserve components. Even though Reserve Specialists do their best to make accurate replacement cost projections, over the course of 30 years some repair & replacement project costs will be “higher than projected” and some will be “lower than projected”. It would be reasonable to expect the highs and lows to “average out” over time.

This would certainly be true for fully-funded Associations (or Associations pursuing a Full Funding objective), which maintain healthy Reserve balances.

Full Funding vs. Baseline Funding Objectives in Practice

Let’s use a hypothetical example where an Association pursuing a Full Funding objective has $500,000 in reserves, with a big asphalt project budgeted to cost $300,000. If the actual project cost turns out to be $350,000 (i.e. $50,000 over budget), the Reserve Fund balance would drop to $150,000 instead of the anticipated $200,000.  At the other extreme, if the actual project cost came in at $250,000 (i.e., $50,000 under budget), the Association would end the year with $250,000 in Reserves. That’s a total swing of $100,000, but there are no ill effects on the Reserve Fund balance or the ability to accomplish the repairs & replacements in a timely manner.

But if a Baseline-funded Association only has the $300,000 in Reserves budgeted for the asphalt project, the Association is in big trouble if the actual project cost turns out (just like in the example above) to be $350,000 ($50,000 over budget). The Association has created a situation where a “deviation from average” on one side (in this case going over-budget) creates a critical problem. Baseline-funding doesn’t provide the margin necessary to allow the “highs” and “lows” to average out over time. Like the basketball team example, repair or replacement projects that cost more than anticipated become game-changers. And the Association suffers the fate of the non-swimmer who drowned in a small, but deep area of a lake that “averaged” three feet deep.

Half and halfThe “Flaw of Averages” explains why Associations striving to make timely repairs & replacements in large expense years with only a barely cash-positive Reserve balance often face a major cash flow problem.  And being unable to complete reserve projects in a timely manner due to insufficient funds has an unfortunate domino effect: deferred maintenance, declining property values, the upheaval of a Special Assessment, or the prospect of applying for a bank loan.

It has been our experience, based on data from over 30,000 Reserve Studies, that baseline-funded Associations suffer these unfortunate consequences about 50% of the time, in those critical, high-expense years. Now that’s a number that needs no explanation!


Other Articles by Paige

FIFTH National Manager of the Year Contest Announces “Top 3” Finalists

Reserve Component Failure Modes – Replace Them on Schedule or Not?

Is Your Reserve Fund On Pace?

The Flaw of Averages!

Voting Now Open for 2016 National “Manager of the Year” Contest’s Top 3 Finalists

National Manager of the Year Contest Announces “Top 10” Finalists

Webinars – A Great Way to Learn About Reserves!

What is Full Funding and Baseline Funding?

Responsible Reserve Funding: Keep Calm & Be Smart!

Straight Line vs. Cash Flow Reserve Funding

Reserve Funding Plans: Selling Out, Settling, or Succeeding

Which Components are (and aren’t) Included?

Reserve Expenses vs. Operating Expenses

Do Plumbing, Electrical, and Landscape Renovation Projects Belong in a Reserve Study?

Reserve Funding Models: What Makes an Association’s Plan Successful?

Board of Directors as Fiduciaries

The Value of a Reserve Study Site Inspection

“Excuses, Excuses”

Deferred Maintenance: Choose Which Repairs to Defer Wisely!

Ignoring the Advice of your Reserve Specialist!

Reserve Study Results – What to Expect

Don't Reserve the Truth

Why Is Accounting For Interest And Inflation Important?

So you want a Reserve Study. Why?

Penny Wise and Pound Foolish

Reserve Studies “Undercover”

The Two Parts of a Reserve Study

Reserve Fund Study Ghosts – Past, Present, and Future!

Why Contribute to Reserves?

Should We Update the Reserve Study Annually?

Planning Your Reserves to Avoid Disasters

How to Get a Great Reserve Study

5 Reasons to Hire a Reserve Specialist

Don’t Pay More Than You Have to for a Reserve Study

Why Update a Reserve Study Annually?

How Do National Reserve Study Standards Benefit You?

Can Reserve Funds be used for Drought-Friendly Landscape Renovations?

Four Ways to Pay for Reserve Expenses

6 Ways to Minimize Your Reserve Contributions

There is no "Whoops" in Reserve Funding

A Whopping 70% of Association-governed Communities are Underfunded